The weak among Al-Aqili and Ibn Adi 1-2

The weak ones between Al-Aqili and Ibn Adi 1-2 The weak ones between Al-Aqili and Ibn Adi through their two books: Al-Dhaeef Al-Kabeer and Al-Kamel fi Al-Dhaeef | Ikrami Muhammad Muhammad Al-Shazli I have preserved the Islamic works in criticism and modification, and in chains of narration and texts, for this nation’s religion, creed, and Sunnah, kept pure away from distortion and forgery despite the distance and change of days and their succession. This book discusses two compilers in criticism and modification, considered a rare scientific treasure in identifying weak men in prophetic hadith, as they collected, confined, and arranged them alphabetically, addressing many names not covered by earlier scholars; thus, Al-Aqili preserved for us the words of the imams of critique regarding the narrators of weakness, mentioning some of what they narrated to demonstrate their weakness. If there is no statement from an imam about a narrator, the compiler addresses their condition. The complete book in weak men by Ibn Adi is the most comprehensive of the books of criticism and modification, upon which the imams rely. Al-Sabki said about it: its name matches its meaning, and its wording agrees with its content, and its judgment is correct, in accordance with what the wise have said, both past and present. When Daraqutni was asked to compile a book on the weak, he directed the questioner to Ibn Adi’s "Weak," saying: it is sufficient, and nothing should be added to it.