The rush of speakers
40.25ر.س
Product description
Dr. Ammar Khunfara The Fall of the Speakers
Book Title: The Fall of the Speakers
Author: Dr. Ammar Khunfar
Publisher: Dar Al-Hijaz Library - Riyadh
Edition: First
Year of Printing: 1441 AH
Number of Pages: 462
Introduction to the subject of the book:
After the first Islamic century, the sects of the theologians appeared, such as the Jahmiyyah and those who followed their way among the Mu'tazilah, Ash'arites, and Maturidites, and they delved into the labyrinths of philosophy; they went astray and led others astray, polluted innate dispositions, and corrupted the objectives of religion with the philosophies they brought. They were neither the most intelligent thinkers, nor the most attentive listeners, nor supporters of reason, nor adherents of Sharia, nor did they bring goodness or benefit to themselves or others; thus, the saying of Allah Almighty is true: {Those whose effort is lost in worldly life, while they think that they are doing good} [Al-Kahf: 104].
Nevertheless, many people fell into the temptation of philosophy and the methods of speech, especially regarding issues related to the self and divine attributes, such as the matter of localization, direction, body, the occurrence of accidents and their succession, and other issues whose sole basis was their proof or denial through what they called rational evidence, making it a measure and standard for judging what relates to Allah's truth or falsehood without relying on explicit revelation and authentic transmission. Otherwise, sound reason does not contradict sound evidence at all.
This book was written to clarify to people the fall of that fabricated theological sect, and to reveal the true methodology imported from the philosophies of other nations, which opposes the methodology of revelation based on clarity, simplicity, depth, without pretense or complexity, and without delving into unseen matters that are not among the objectives of religion, nor are humans commanded to enter into, investigate, or inquire about them. These issues do not increase faith or grant light and certainty; rather, they are darkness, confusion, misguidance, doubts, and contradictions.
This book is divided into three chapters. The author in the first chapter discusses some of the foundational and theological issues of the theologians, clarifying the corrupt aspects of them and their reflection on their other arguments, proofs, and principles. It contains three sections:
The first: on the space and direction, including definitions of some theologians of the space, such as Al-Razi, and criticism of these definitions, discussion of their arguments, and refutation of their doubts.
The second: on substance and accident, presenting the sects of the theologians and then the sects of philosophers in this regard, along with some of the Ash'arites' doubts about body and accident, and refuting them.
The third: on accidents and denying the occurrence of actions by Allah, and related topics about time, eternity, the eternity of the universe, the succession of actions, and others.
In the second chapter, the author presents the most famous rational proofs used by the theologians to deny Allah's exaltation over His creation, along with refutations of these proofs and demonstrating their invalidity. It includes six sections: the first introduces the concept of knowledge and how it is acquired, discussing axioms, primary truths, sensory perceptions, impossibilities, necessities, theories, illusions, and imaginations, among others.
The second: discusses Allah's exaltation between necessity and consideration, mentioning that theologians have two opinions regarding the matter of place: the first is that Allah exists everywhere, and the second is that Allah is not in a place, so it is not said that Allah is inside or outside the universe. The author clearly refutes the first opinion and finds no need to discuss it, then examines the second opinion, which is the view of most theologians from the Mu'tazilah, Ash'arites, and others. He presents premises and arguments of Al-Razi with responses, noting that Al-Razi—according to the author's words—expanded more on this issue than any other theologian or philosopher before or after him. The author concludes this section by stating that the theologians, despite their different sects, did not provide a single proof for the correctness of their statements, and all their arguments are based on analogy with existing possibilities in the universe, with no proof whatsoever for the negation of Allah's transcendence.
The third: discusses the issue of seeing Allah Almighty; among the most contradictory statements of the theologians is their claim that seeing Allah in the Hereafter is permissible, while they believe that Allah has no direction. How can one see something if it is not in a direction?! They also tried to justify this contradiction with statements presented by the author and refuted.
The fourth chapter: presents the most common arguments of the theologians relied upon to deny Allah's elevation, localization, and specific direction, with discussion and rebuttal, focusing on what Fakhr al-Din Al-Razi mentioned in his books "Al-Matali' al-A'liya" (his final work) and "Forty Principles of Religion" he wrote for his son, to teach him the methods of this science, without quoting other theologians' words, for several reasons mentioned by the author.
The fifth: discusses what the theologians said about incarnation and composition; because they established that proving Allah's exaltation entails composition and incarnation, which they consider false beliefs, and from this, it follows that Allah's exaltation cannot be affirmed. The author presents Al-Razi's arguments on this matter and shows that he fell into contradictions, doubts, and unfounded assumptions that do not lead to certainty.
The sixth: criticizes the sect of the theologians regarding their claims about substance and accident to prove the occurrence of the universe, demonstrating that their reasoning is weak in light of modern science, which refutes their theological theories on this issue, such as the modern proof of the atom's capacity for division and fission.
The third part: contains five chapters. The first discusses the reason behind the theologians' reliance on rational evidence, and the author clarifies the invalidity of relying solely on pure rational evidence, mentioning six problems faced by those who depend only on reason and make it the judge over sacred texts.
The second: on methods of reasoning used by the theologians, elaborating on analogy, generalization, and induction among logicians and philosophers.
The third: dedicated to discussing analogy in faith-related unseen matters among the theologians, considering it one of the causes that led some of them into deep misguidance.
The fourth: presents various examples of the contradictions and weaknesses in the rational methodology of the theologians, indicating its corruption, including their fall into circular reasoning, where a premise is stated and then built upon to reach a conclusion, and in another place, the conclusion is used as a premise to prove the original premise, making each premise dependent on the other.
The fifth: on the relationship between philosophers and theologians, where the author explains in detail that the foundations of the theologians' sects, from the Mu'tazilah and Ash'arites, are not their own inventions but are borrowed from philosophers and Greek logicians and others; their principles are taken from them, and even the proofs used by the theologians were derived from them, with differences in details and branches. Nonetheless, they called these borrowed topics the foundations of religion! The author provides examples from the theories of philosophers like Aristotle and Plotinus and the influence on theologians.
The author concludes the book by stating that what is called the science of theology, in general, and most of its forms and examples, was not present to defend the beliefs of the religion against disbelievers, but rather to defend the beliefs of the theologians themselves against each other. Anyone who reflects on the writings of the theologians will find that other Islamic sects and their responses to each other are many times more numerous than their responses to philosophers, atheists, materialists, and followers of other religions.
Questions you might have

