The jurisprudence, religion, and authority: the dialectical political thought of Shia.

51.75

Out of Stock

Product description

The jurisprudence, religion, and authority: the controversy of Shiite political thought Author: Muhammad bin Saqr Al-Sulami / Muhammad Al-Sayyid Al-Sayyad Publisher: Center of the Arabian Gulf for Iranian Studies Researcher: Cover type: Glazed Edition number: First Publication date: 1438 AH The importance of this book's topic comes from it being one of the first books to study the relationship between Iran and Arab Shiism from the perspective of the theory of political and constitutional jurisprudence, because theories of political jurisprudence are the main entry point to the disagreements of the post-Khomeini Iranian state with the Arab jurist and Arab authority. The relationship between Iran and Arab Shiism has been studied from a political and strategic perspective, but there is no comprehensive study that explains and breaks down the intellectual and ideological relationships, the points of disagreement and their social dimensions, anthropological contexts, religious and doctrinal backgrounds, between the supreme authority — before and after Khomeini — and the Arab authority. It also examines the development of this relationship, its cohesion factors, and its determinants in the Hawza mind, i.e., the nature of the conflict between the jurist and the Arab authority, and between the jurist and the Iranian authority, as well as resources that color the personality of the Iranian authority through the Khomeini reading of political theory, which widened the gap between Arab and Persian jurists. Shiite political thought has seen debates and theories since the events of the constitutional revolution until today. Each school relies on a set of juristic, foundational, and philosophical elements within the doctrine, all centered on the role of the jurist and the extent of his influence within the authority institution, and whether his tasks in governance and authority are part of or outside the jurist’s responsibilities. Thus, religion/doctrine was pulled between the jurist and the authority, sometimes through interpretation and other times through utilization, which sparked political, juristic, and philosophical activism that reflected on Iranian society and Shiism in general. Iranian political thought was transnational, as it emanated from references and Ayatollahs speaking on behalf of Shiism, creating a debate and exchange of opinions among Shiite references inside and outside Iran, between those who reject Iranian political theory as a product of a hybrid Persian-Shiite mixture, and those who adopt it as it represents a movement and reform within the doctrine that is necessary. Undoubtedly, this juristic and political activism forms a strong foundation and guiding philosophy for Iranian politicians. Therefore, studying and exploring its depths is considered an understanding of contemporary Iranian political philosophy, its strategic determinants, its current and future influence and positions. In this book, we also aim to dismantle the Iranian religious institution and monitor its relationships with the Arab authority, and how those relationships shifted from alliances and integration during the pre-Khomeini era to rivalry and dominance during and after Khomeini. This is due to the overturning of the Shiite jurisprudential heritage and Hawza customs by Khomeini, within the scope of constitutional jurisprudence, as Khomeini worked to impose his jurisprudential choices and convictions, intertwined with personal ambitions and nationalist backgrounds, on the Shiite Hawza. He succeeded in Qom through power and law by institutionalizing his theory in the constitution and law, as will be discussed later. However, if this was not achieved regarding the Arab Hawza in Iraq and Lebanon, he worked to contain and tame it through other means, which the study observed. The main points of disagreement between the Khomeini school and the Arab authorities were concentrated in political issues. No doubt, the political disagreement produced a juristic dispute. After Najaf was advocating for the Iranian constitutional revolution in 1906 through the jurist Naini, and after Shirazi from Samarra intervened in the Tabriz events in Iran, Khomeini began theorizing Shiite political jurisprudence, attempting to erase previous and contemporary efforts of ijtihad, and to impose his jurisprudential options on Najaf, the mother school of Shiism worldwide. He worked diligently to nationalize the Shiite authority in favor of his jurisprudential choices and doctrinal convictions. These political disagreements over theories of political and constitutional jurisprudence led to deep divisions within the doctrine itself, and a broad scholarly movement. Although they influenced the Hawza’s academic paths, they enriched the theory of political jurisprudence in the Arab Shiite school after being provoked by Khomeini’s outputs in state jurisprudence. The disagreement expanded between the traditionalists and the foundationalists, then the gap widened among the foundationalists themselves, leading to internal splits that resulted in opposition currents, which soon crystallized into new, influential sects within the Shiite community, representing a form of intellectual richness in political and doctrinal jurisprudence, regardless of the principle of correctness and truthfulness in the political fundamentals of Shiism. The book also monitors Khomeini’s position within the Iranian Shiite Hawza before the revolution, and his position within Shiite authority in general. This helps us understand the motives behind his ijtihad and his standing in the Hawza. It also tracks the intellectual transformations and developments in Khomeini, and how these affected his position in the Hawza, his relationships with his peers, teachers, and mentors. The study also examines the position of the masses in Khomeini’s philosophy, and how this influenced the disagreement between him and Arab jurists and scholars. Additionally, the book concludes by analyzing the political effects built upon Khomeini’s theory, which widened the gap between the Arab and Persian authorities. Understanding contemporary Iranian behavior toward the region and the broader area cannot be achieved solely through political analyses and reactions. Precise understanding requires a detailed deconstructive study of the philosophical foundations of the Iranian state since its ideological inception by Khomeini, and its jurisprudential and philosophical roots within Shiite and Persian thought. Because Iranian political behavior is not arbitrary but rooted in ideology and thought, and no policy is made without an ideological basis. Decision-makers and policymakers still operate within the ideological jurisprudential school. Any authority must have intellectual and ideological premises for governance, management, and legislation. The theory of Wilayat al-Faqih remains the ideological foundation of Iran’s ruling system, still strong and deeply rooted in cultural, educational, and institutional environments. It continues to be a strategic determinant in Iran’s relations with the Shiite Arab other. Therefore, its destabilization over the long term is extremely difficult if only reactive responses are considered, focusing on surface reactions rather than core principles. This is why this book is important: it seeks to deconstruct and analyze the structural composition of the Wilayat al-Faqih institution, its current and historical relationship with the Shiite religious establishment inside and outside Iran, clarifying its weaknesses, strengths, and durability to this day. Consequently, it helps Arab decision-makers understand Iran’s behavior and its ideological and doctrinal motives toward the region and the broader area. It also provides insight into the psychological makeup of the founders of the Iranian state and their successors, the “first and second generations,” who remain in power today. This enables the formulation of precise policies for dealing with this rebellious state against international laws and neighborly norms. Furthermore, this book is a strong message to Arab Shiites, drawing their attention to the significance of the Arab religious authority’s historical and cultural position, including its jurisprudential and foundational heritage that contributed to shaping the collective Shiite mind during the pre-Khomeini era, before the entire doctrine and sect were hijacked by Persian Shiism, which re-emerged under Khomeini’s leadership.

Questions you might have

‌
‌
‌‌
‌
‌
‌‌
‌
‌
‌‌
‌
‌
‌‌
‌
‌
‌‌
‌
‌
‌‌
‌