The doctrinal criticisms of the book Revival of Religious Sciences
74.75ر.س
Out of Stock
Product description
Preparation by Dr. Abdullah bin Ubaid bin Ebad Al-Otaibi
The doctrinal foundations on the book of "Reviving the Sciences of Religion" - a quarter of acts of worship, and a quarter of customs
Title of the book: The doctrinal foundations on the book of "Reviving the Sciences of Religion" - a quarter of acts of worship, and a quarter of customs
Type: Doctoral thesis - Umm Al-Qura University
Publisher: Dar Al-Hadith Al-Nabawi – Dar Al-Fadila
Year of printing: 1436 AH – 2015 AD
Number of pages: 598
Introduction to the subject of the book:
It is well known that Imam Abu Hamid Al-Ghazali, may Allah have mercy on him, is one of the prominent figures in the field of Islamic studies, and he has a wide audience of readers. He is described as one of the most intelligent scholars in the world, as Sheikh Al-Islam Ibn Taimiya described him. However, he delved into every grievance, attacked every problem, and wrote in several sciences, especially in creed.
One of his most famous and important books is "Reviving the Sciences of Religion," which was among the last writings he penned, containing what his knowledge and understanding had reached. In it, he reviewed issues of creed in the manner of the theologians - Ash'aris - which is contrary to the way of the Salaf, who were not experts in their methodology and approach to the fundamentals of religion. Likewise, Ghazali also addressed Islamic acts of worship such as prayer, fasting, Zakat, Hajj, and others, setting incorrect concepts, types of innovations, and things without basis in these acts.
It is worth noting that Ghazali divided this book into four parts: a quarter of acts of worship, a quarter of customs, a quarter of destructive matters, and a quarter of salvific matters. Each part contains ten books:
- The quarter of acts of worship includes: the book of knowledge, the book of creed principles, the book of secrets of purification, the book of secrets of prayer, the book of secrets of Zakat, the book of secrets of fasting, the book of secrets of Hajj, the book of Quran recitation, the book of remembrances, the book of supplications.
- The quarter of customs includes: the book of manners of eating, the book of manners of earning, the book of manners of marriage, the book of lawful and unlawful, the book of manners of companionship, the book of solitude, the book of manners of travel, the book of listening, the book of enjoining good, the book of manners of living, the book of the morals of Prophethood.
This week's book is one of the books that monitored Ghazali's errors and transgressions in these two quarters of his "Reviving the Sciences of Religion."
The author divided the book into an introduction, a preface, three chapters, and a conclusion. In the introduction, he mentioned the importance of the topic, reasons for choosing it, the methodology of research, and from his approach in the book:
1. He followed Ghazali’s order in "Reviving the Sciences of Religion" for easier handling and review.
2. He first mentioned the foundations and errors, then followed with comments on them.
3. He introduced the sects, schools, and scholars mentioned in the research, among other well-known matters in such studies.
In the preface, he discussed the definition of Ghazali and his book "Reviving the Sciences of Religion," addressing the political and social situation of Imam Al-Ghazali's era, then talked about his life and scholarly آثار.
Then, he dedicated a section to the opinions of scholars about Ghazali and his book "Reviving the Sciences of Religion," mentioning the views of Al-Turtushi, Abu Abdullah Al-Mazri, Ibn Al-Arabi, Ibn Al-Jawzi, Ibn Taimiya, and some of their criticisms and objections to "Reviving," which mainly focus on Ghazali’s critique of some of what he states and describes as recommended and lawful, which has no basis, as well as his accumulation of numerous weak and fabricated hadiths, and his reliance on sources like Ibn Sina, the Brothers of Purity, and Al-Tawhidi, who are neither trustworthy nor reliable for Islamic creeds.
The first chapter discusses Ghazali’s methodology in his book "Reviving the Sciences of Religion," divided into four sections:
- The first section discusses Ghazali’s method of reasoning, defining the terms "method" and "reasoning," and describing the components and methods of reasoning used by Ghazali.
- The second section discusses Ghazali’s sources in "Reviving the Sciences of Religion" and evaluates these sources briefly, including theological sources based on Al-Juwayni’s "Al-Irshad" and "Al-Shamil," and Sufi sources like "Qut Al-Qulub" by Abu Talib Al-Makki, works of Harith Al-Muhasibi, and miscellaneous sayings of Al-Junaid and Al-Shibli, then examines and evaluates these sources.
- The third section discusses the impact of "Reviving the Sciences of Religion" on the Ash'ari school, noting its significant role in spreading this doctrine, as Ghazali presented Ash'ari creed in an organized, clear, and accessible manner, which facilitated its dissemination among those who highly regard the book, especially Sufis. It also discusses the influence of the book on philosophical Sufism.
- The fourth section addresses the doctrinal foundations of "Reviving the Sciences of Religion," mentioning Ghazali’s use of theological methodology to establish creed, his adoption of the innovative Sufi approach for self-purification and gaining knowledge, and issues like reliance on fabricated and weak hadiths, among other matters.
The second chapter is dedicated to doctrinal foundations related to Ghazali in the acts of worship, divided into seven sections:
- The first section discusses doctrinal foundations regarding Ghazali’s views on divine transcendence, the approach of theologians in divine transcendence, and their deviation from the Quran and Sunnah. It also covers Ghazali’s views on the declaration of "There is no god but Allah" and responses to them.
- The second section discusses doctrinal foundations regarding Ghazali’s views on divine attributes, explaining Ghazali’s approach, affirming seven attributes called "metaphysical attributes," and responding to his denial of voluntary attributes.
- The third section covers doctrinal foundations regarding Ghazali’s views on divine actions, clarifying the meaning of actions, discussing important issues related to Allah’s actions, and elaborating on them according to Sunni and Jama'ah creed, including:
1. All of Allah’s actions are good, and evil is not attributable to Him.
2. Allah is wise in His actions and what He legislates for His servants.
3. The issue of rationally enhancing and degrading (good and bad), and its relation to obligation.
4. The issue of human ability’s effect on their actions and its relation to Allah’s actions.
After presenting these issues, the author discusses doctrinal foundations regarding Ghazali’s views on divine commands.
- The fourth section discusses doctrinal foundations regarding Ghazali’s views on transmitted matters, defining transmitted matters in the terminology of theologians, and listing doctrinal foundations regarding Ghazali’s views on transmitted matters, including his view on the punishment of the grave, responding to his specific description of the punishment of the grave to certain parts of the body that perceive and feel pain, and clarifying that this is not supported by evidence, and that the apparent meaning of the texts indicates that punishment occurs to spirits and bodies, among other issues.
- The fifth section discusses doctrinal foundations regarding Ghazali’s views on Islam and faith, clarifying that Ghazali’s issues of faith align with the Ash'ari school leaning towards extremism in this matter, and that he considers actions not part of true faith in Sharia. The author criticizes this, stating it contradicts the Salaf’s view that faith is statement, action, and belief. He also criticizes Ghazali’s definition of faith as heart conviction, with actions and speech as mere complements, asserting that Ghazali’s position is that of the Ash'aris, and that the lawful faith includes speech, deeds, and heart belief, supported by Quran, Sunnah, and the sayings of the Salaf.
He also discusses Ghazali’s view on the status of actions in faith, and the issue of increasing and decreasing faith, among other matters.
- The sixth section covers doctrinal foundations regarding Ghazali’s views on the secrets of acts of worship, defining worship as a comprehensive term for all acts prescribed by Allah, whether obligatory or recommended, involving conditions for validity such as sincerity to Allah and conformity to the Muhammadan Sharia. It also discusses the ruling on innovations in religion, defining innovation as a new way in religion that resembles Sharia, intended to exaggerate worship to Allah.
He then explains doctrinal foundations regarding Ghazali’s views on innovations and acts of innovation in acts of worship, criticizing Ghazali’s prohibition of facing the sun and moon when answering the call of nature, noting that some scholars said it was disliked rather than forbidden, and that this matter is unsupported by evidence, contradicting the Prophet’s (peace be upon him) saying: "When you go to relieve yourself, do not face the Qibla nor turn away from it, but face east or west."
He also discusses doctrinal foundations and innovations in the secrets of prayer, Zakat, fasting, and Hajj.
- The seventh section discusses doctrinal foundations regarding Ghazali’s views on manners of reciting the Quran, remembrances, supplications, and night prayer, starting with the correct methodology in dhikr, supplication, and Quran recitation, then listing doctrinal foundations related to Ghazali’s views on all these matters.
The third part of the book deals with doctrinal foundations in the customs section of "Reviving the Sciences of Religion," divided into three chapters:
- The first chapter discusses foundations related to Ghazali’s views on manners after eating, criticizing his statement that reading "Say: He is Allah, the One" and "For the accustomed company of Quraish" are among the manners after eating, which is unsupported by evidence. It also criticizes Ghazali’s view that it is disliked to have intercourse at the beginning and end of the month and at the beginning of the night, which are also unsupported by evidence.
- The second chapter discusses foundations and errors regarding Ghazali’s views in the book "Manners of earning and livelihood" and "Permissible and forbidden."
- The third chapter reviews foundations and mistakes regarding Ghazali’s views in the book "Listening and spiritual ecstasy," criticizing his definition of listening as listening to poetic verses with melodious voices, sometimes accompanied by drumming, clapping, and similar acts, and responding to Ghazali’s claim that singing excites spiritual ecstasy more than the Quran. The author refutes Ghazali’s permissiveness of listening.
The author concludes the book with a summary of the most important findings:
- That "Reviving the Sciences of Religion" was subject to criticism by scholars during Ghazali’s life and after his death; excessive veneration of this book or of Ghazali himself contradicts the correct Islamic guidance.
- That Ghazali included many doctrinal, verbal, and practical innovations in "Reviving," making it a source for many widespread innovations in the Islamic world.
- That "Reviving" contains incorrect perceptions about concepts such as Tawhid, reliance, asceticism, worship, and others.
The book is good in its field.
Questions you might have



