Judgment by lineage
40.25ر.س
Product description
Fouad Muhammad Al-Majid
Author's Name: Fouad Muhammad Al-Majid
Researcher’s Name: Adnan Muhammad Al-Daqil
Publisher: Dar Ibn Al-Jawzi - Dammam
Book Format: Artistic binding, glossy paper
Publication Date: 1433-2022
Book Size: 24×17
Number of Pages: 320
Summary of the Thesis
Judgment by Al-Qiyafa (tracking/kinship identification)
Al-Asfahani explained the exclusivity of Arabs in knowing the linkage of lineages: "Allah Almighty has distinguished the Arabs for this, to be a reason for restraining their women from what leads to defamation of their lineage, and the evil of their descent, and the corruption of their seeds and crops," meaning it is a preservation granted by Allah for their lineages.
Islam did not neglect the matter of Al-Qiyafa; rather, it considered it a means of proof in some claims. This consideration is not derived from pre-Islamic customs but is divine legislation that coincidentally aligns with some pre-Islamic customs where they were correct, and Islam came with similar provisions.
Since Al-Qiyafa helps achieve the objectives of Sharia in preserving life, lineage, and property, and since its topic has not been given a dedicated independent research despite its importance, I decided that my supplementary research for the second year at the Higher Institute of Judiciary - Department of Jurisprudence Policy - would be on Judging by Al-Qiyafa.
I have invested much time and effort in preparing this research, and I do not claim its perfection; only Allah is perfect.
It is also clear that there is a decline in determination in this era and many preoccupations. This research is merely the effort of a humble person, a modest offering, and I do not consider myself a researcher but rather someone imitating them.
Al-Suhrawardi said:
"Imitate if you cannot be like them,
Indeed, imitation of the noble is success."
In this research, I followed the approach and terminology as follows:
1- Extensive review of books of Tafsir, Hadith, Fiqh, Fiqh Principles, and Usul related to Al-Qiyafa, and transferring what is important for writing the research.
2- Collecting and studying verses and Hadiths that explicitly or implicitly mention Al-Qiyafa.
3- Relying mostly on original and old references, and only using modern sources for consultation or when the original reference could not be found.
4- Referencing forensic medicine and criminal investigation books to explore recent discoveries, adding innovation to the research on Al-Qiyafa.
5- When there is a disagreement on a matter, I present the schools of thought of the jurists and usually clarify their evidence, mentioning objections afterward. If there is something to respond to the objections, I do so.
I sometimes support some schools of thought with evidence they did not mention or mentioned elsewhere if I find it relevant. I also oppose and respond, and I begin such statements with the word "perhaps," for example: "Perhaps they can be supported by such and such," then I choose what appears to me to be the strongest evidence and most consistent with the leniency and ease of Islamic Sharia, explaining my preference for the opinion I choose.
6- When citing a source for the first time in the margin, I usually specify its full name, author, edition, and publication date.
7- When I say a Hadith is narrated by the group, it means it is narrated by Bukhari, Muslim, Ahmad, Tirmidhi, Nasa’i, Abu Dawood, and Ibn Majah, as per the terminology of Majd al-Din Abdul Salam ibn Taymiyah in his book "Al-Muntaqa."
The research is divided into:
Introduction, eight chapters, and a conclusion.
A- Introduction: On the methods of judgment and the status of Al-Qiyafa among them.
It includes four topics:
First topic: Explaining the meaning of methods of judgment.
Second topic: Explaining methods of judgment.
Third topic: Types of methods of judgment.
Fourth topic: The status of Al-Qiyafa among methods of judgment.
B- The eight chapters:
1- First chapter: Definition of Al-Qiyafa, including six points:
First point: Explanation of its meaning.
Second point: Its pillars.
Third point: Its general categories.
Fourth point: Evidence for its legality.
Fifth point: Wisdom behind its legality.
Sixth point: The difference between Al-Qiyafa and Firasah (intuition/insight).
2- Second chapter: On clues (al-ara’), including three sections:
First section: Definition of clues and their relation to Al-Qiyafa, including four points:
- Meaning of clues linguistically and terminologically.
- Types of clues.
- Conditions for acting upon clues.
- The relation of Al-Qiyafa to clues.
Second section: The ruling on acting upon clues, including three points:
- Opinions of jurists regarding acting upon clues.
- Evidence, with two branches:
- Evidence supporting the permissibility from the Qur'an, Sunnah, consensus, and rational reasoning.
- Evidence against acting upon clues from the Sunnah and rational reasoning.
- Preference among these opinions.
Third section: The ruling on acting upon clues in Hudood (punishments) and blood claims, including two points:
- The ruling on acting upon clues in Hudood, with three branches:
- Clues in adultery: pregnancy, presence of a foreign man with the woman, refusal of the wife to perform Lian (oath of innocence), differences in the child's resemblance, and blood type differences.
- Clues in drinking: smell, vomit, intoxication, presence of alcohol at the accused, and medical test results.
- Clues in theft: presence of stolen money with the accused, and traces of the accused at the theft scene.
- The ruling on acting upon clues in blood claims.
3- Third chapter: Considering Al-Qiyafa as a means to prove or deny lineage and establish Faraash (legitimate bed), including two sections:
First section: Proving and denying lineage through Al-Qiyafa, including three points:
- Proving lineage by Al-Qiyafa.
- Denying lineage by Al-Qiyafa.
- How to perform Al-Qiyafa among humans, with two branches:
- How Al-Qiyafa was performed among early peoples.
- How Al-Qiyafa is performed among modern humans, including blood analysis and external resemblance.
Second section: On Faraash (legitimate bed), including three points:
- Meaning of Faraash.
- How Faraash is confirmed.
- The levels of Faraash.
4- Fourth chapter: Conditions for judging by Al-Qiyafa, starting with the condition of dispute over the child's lineage, which is a prerequisite for other conditions, then discussing its three states, followed by three sections:
First section: Conditions involved in the three states, all agreed upon.
Second section: Conditions involved in two states.
Third section: The two conditions involved in only one state.
5- Fifth chapter: Conditions for the Al-Qiyaf (the tracker), including three sections:
First section: Conditions according to Malikis.
Second section: Conditions according to Shafi’is.
Third section: Conditions according to Hanbalis.
Then I selected what I found to be the strongest conditions and explained why.
6- Sixth chapter: The ruling on judging by Al-Qiyafa among humans, including three sections:
First section: Opinions of jurists on judging by Al-Qiyafa.
Second section: Evidence, organized into two points:
- Evidence supporting the permissibility from the Sunnah, consensus, and rational analogy.
- Evidence against from the Sunnah, consensus, and rational analogy.
Third section: Preference among these opinions.
7- Seventh chapter: Al-Qiyafa of traces, including five sections:
First section: Effects of footstep impressions.
Second section: Fingerprint impressions.
Third section: Police dogs and scent effects.
Fourth section: Blood trace analysis.
Fifth section: Voice analysis.
8- Eighth chapter: Al-Qiyafa of money, divided into two parts:
First part: Linking the branch to its original by resemblance.
Second part: Conventional clues that link money to its owner more than to its opponent.
C- Conclusion: Outlining the findings regarding judging by Al-Qiyafa, emphasizing that working with it broadens the scope of judgment, preserves lives, lineages, and property.
I pray to Allah Almighty to accept our efforts, guide us to the straight path, and reward our teacher, His Eminence Sheikh Dr. Abdul Aal Atiyah, whose valuable guidance greatly influenced the appearance of this research. I also thank everyone who contributed with assistance and guidance from my teachers and brothers. May Allah reward them all with goodness.
All praise is due to Allah first and last, and Allah is the grant of success.
Questions you might have

