The opinions of Orientalists and their approaches in criticizing Hadith
51.75ر.س
Product description
Book title: Opinions of Orientalists and Their Approaches in Critiquing Hadith
Subtitle: An Analytical Critical Comparative Study (Herald Motski as a Model)
Author: Dr. Muhammad Zubairi
Number of pages: 404 pages
Size: 17 by 24 cm
To download the summary from here
Summary:
The perspective of Orientalism towards Islamic narrations has evolved from the principle of doubt and denial of their credibility to viewing them with balance and rationality. Over time, their study mainly focused on dating the narrations, aiming to identify the oldest version or narration of the texts, how they spread, where they spread, and who published them.
The book generally reviews the emergence of Orientalism, then the development of its critical view towards Hadith books in particular, with a focus on the German Orientalist Herald Motski as a model. It also discusses his opinions on the science of Hadith, the criticisms directed at him, and his views on the approaches of previous Orientalists in studying Islamic narrations, with an emphasis on the approach of "studying the chain of narration and the text in an integrated manner" adopted by Motski in analyzing the narrations about the murder of Ibn Abi al-Haqiq and the narrations of the Hadith of the cat.
The book does not only mention supporters of this approach but also includes some responses from other Orientalists to this method, along with Motski’s replies to them. It also demonstrates that different narrations of the same story often do not originate from fabrications or distortions by narrators but occur during narration for reasons explained in the book.
The researcher, through his analytical study, confirmed that the methodology of the Hadith scholars is more effective than that of the Orientalists, although there are points of convergence between the two approaches.
Questions you might have

