Removing blame from the great imams
23ر.س
Product description
Ahmed bin Abdul Halim bin Abdul Salam bin Taymiyah
Printed edition checked against five handwritten copies
Removing blame from the noble imams.
A book authored by Ibn Taymiyah, the title indicates its content;
Removing blame from the noble imams,
He mentioned the reasons for the differing opinions of the scholars of the nation in some branches of Islamic jurisprudence issues, and that this does not diminish their status and value, and that it was not driven by personal whims.
The motivation behind writing this book was the blame issued by some people towards some of the scholars of the nation for their disagreement with some of the hadiths of the Prophet, peace be upon him.
Thus, the goal of this book was to remove that blame from them and justify their stance.
It was necessary to clarify to people that that blame is false speech.
Ibn Taymiyah here specifically refers to the scholars of the nation, not any student of knowledge who may err and repeat mistakes from himself.
And in this regard, the Prophet, peace be upon him, said:
"Judges are three: two in the Fire, and one in Paradise.
As for the one in Paradise, he is a man who knew the truth and acted upon it,
and the two in the Fire are: a man who judged for the people out of ignorance,
and a man who knew the truth but judged contrary to it."
Ibn Taymiyah said in the book:
And know that none of the imams intentionally contradicts the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him,
for they are unanimously agreed upon the obligation of following the Prophet, peace be upon him,
and that everyone from the people is to be accepted or rejected from his statement except the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him.
But if one of them finds a statement with a sound hadith contrary to it,
he must have an excuse for leaving it.
Importance of the book
In it, Ibn Taymiyah defended the logicality of differences among the fatwas of the Islamic scholars, which is considered an important matter among Muslims,
due to the necessity of steadfastness, firmness, piety, and competence of those from whom they take their religion.
It was mentioned in the book of Al-Jarh wa Ta'dil:
"And one of the most beneficial writings in this field is the book 'Removing Blame from the Noble Imams'…
It is worthy, if it were in China, to be traveled to, and to be bitten by the molars on it.
May Allah have mercy on those who make excuses for the imams, and know that their effort is only towards the truth and guidance."
Sheikh Abdul Aziz bin Baz said regarding the excuses of jurists:
"As elaborated by the eminent scholar, Sheikh Islam Ibn Taymiyah, may Allah have mercy on him, in his great book 'Removing Blame from the Noble Imams,'
which he excelled in and benefited from, and clarified the excuses of scholars in what they disagreed with from the Shariah,
so review it, as it is very beneficial for the seeker of truth."
In explaining Sunan Abu Dawood:
"Scholars have written in this regard writings and apologies for the imams when authentic hadiths are found that oppose what one of them saw,
and one of the best writings in this is a valuable treatise by Ibn Taymiyah, may Allah have mercy on him, titled 'Removing Blame from the Noble Imams.'"
Topics of the book
The reasons Ibn Taymiyah mentioned for the occurrence of disagreement
Ibn Taymiyah divided these excuses into three main reasons:
1- Not believing that the Prophet, peace be upon him, said it.
2- Not believing that the intention behind that matter was with that statement.
3- Believing that the ruling is abrogated.
Then Ibn Taymiyah elaborated on these excuses into ten causes, summarized as:
1- The hadith did not reach him:
And from that is the story of the grandmother’s inheritance, when Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, was asked about it, he said:
There is nothing in the Book of Allah about it, nor in the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, about it, but I will ask the people.
He asked them, so Al-Mughirah ibn Shubah and Muhammad ibn Muslimah, may Allah be pleased with them, stood and testified that the Prophet, peace be upon him, gave her.
2- The hadith reached him but was not established in his knowledge:
It is mentioned in the book:
"Indeed, the hadiths had spread and become famous, but they reached many scholars through weak chains, and others through authentic chains that are not like the others, so it is a proof from this aspect, even though it did not reach those who opposed it from this aspect."
3- Belief that the hadith is weak due to an opposing opinion:
One may see the narrator of the hadith as weak, while another sees him as trustworthy.
And among those who considered the narrator weak is Ibrahim ibn Muhammad ibn Abi Yahya Abu Ishaq al-Madani,
while Shafi’i considered him good.
4- Requiring in the authentic report that the judge be just and a حافظ (memorizer) with conditions that others do not agree with:
Among these is some scholars’ condition that the hadith be checked against the Quran and Sunnah,
and some require that the narrator be a jurist if he contradicts the principles of jurisprudence,
and some require that the hadith be widespread and apparent if it involves a widespread issue… etc.
5- The hadith reached him and was established but he forgot it:
And from that is Omar ibn Al-Khattab, may Allah be pleased with him, forgetting the hadith of Tayammum when asked about a man who is junub in travel and cannot find water?
He said: He should not pray until he finds water.
It was mentioned by Ammar with an incident that happened to them and they informed the Prophet, peace be upon him, about it, so the Prophet said to them:
"It would suffice you that way,"
and he struck the ground with his hands and wiped his face and hands.
6- Not knowing the indication of the hadith:
This may be due to the presence of a strange word in the hadith that may differ in interpretation among scholars,
such as in the hadith: "The Prophet, peace be upon him, forbade Muzabana."
Or it may be a language difference between the original and customary usage, as in wine, for example, where the term "nabeed" is used for water sweetening (like soaked dates).
7- Believing that the indication in the hadith is not to be taken:
And Ibn Taymiyah mentioned many reasons for this, including that a command alone does not imply obligation or urgency,
or that the known with the "lam" (the definite article) is not general,
or that the negated actions do not negate their own selves or all their rulings, etc.
8- Believing that the indication was opposed by what indicates it is not intended:
Like opposing the general with the specific, or the absolute with the restricted, or the absolute command with what negates obligation, etc.
9- Believing that the hadith is opposed by what indicates its weakness, abrogation, or interpretation that makes it an opposition.
10- Opposing it with what indicates its weakness, abrogation, or interpretation:
which others do not believe that its kind opposes, or that it is not truly opposed but a weak opposition.
Examples include many Kufan hadith contradicting the apparent Quran, believing that the apparent Quran of generality and similar matters take precedence over the text of the hadith.
And also rejecting a report that specifies a generality in the Quran, or restricts its absolute, or adds to it.
And also opposing a group of Madinan scholars’ authentic hadith with the practice of the people of Medina, based on their consensus to oppose the report, and that their consensus is a proof that takes precedence over the hadith, such as opposing the hadith of the best of the sale’s bargain.
While the option of the sale’s bargain is established in Bukhari and Muslim.
Warnings about punishment
Then Ibn Taymiyah, in the continuation of the book, discussed the hadiths of warning, giving examples of how scholars differ on them and how some specify some over others.
Including the hadith of the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him:
"When two Muslims meet with their swords, the killer and the killed are in the Fire."
Its apparent meaning is the prohibition of fighting among believers.
He then mentioned:
"And we know that the people of Jamal and Siffin are not in the Fire, because they have an excuse and a valid interpretation in fighting, and good deeds prevented the action."
Another example is the hadith:
"Three people Allah will not speak to, nor look at, nor purify them on the Day of Resurrection, and they will have a painful punishment:
a man who withholds water from the traveler, saying to Allah: Today I will prevent you from my favor as you prevented the favor of what your hands did not produce…"
Ibn Taymiyah elaborated on this, raising multiple issues and questions for discussion, along with providing answers.
This requires reviewing the entire book and reading it fully, and cannot be summarized.
Questions you might have

